The Great Omission

To borrow Steve Saint’s expansion of an old analogy, rather than feeding the world spiritual fish, I want to “Distribute spiritual fish samples and then train all those who want more to fish for themselves AND teach them to teach others to fish.”

I won’t claim that this is the best quote from The Great Omission, Saint’s book that I just finished reading, but I will say that you should read the book. Perhaps part of the book’ allure was my engineering mind’s connection with his good number pictures. Saint’s effective use of stories that were both entertaining and illustrative also contributed to the excellence of the book. But the bottom line of the book, its driving force, was that the wealthy western church needs to facilitate rather than hinder ministry by indigenous believers.

The wealthy west needs to stop nurturing dependence. Rather than working to give people what they need on a limited scale, we should focus on making it possible for people everywhere to acquire what they need. Rather than building a church for one group of people (and in so doing discouraging all other churches in the area from sacrificial building projects, encouraging them to wait for the infinite wealth of the west) we should find ways to bolster their economy and we should engineer new, more efficient means of building churches.

Steve Saint told a story of one church built for the Waodani. They didn’t know to whom the church belonged (because it had been built by someone else), so they didn’t know who to ask for permission to repair it. It therefore fell to pieces. Further, they could not reproduce the initial grandeur of the donated church, and therefore ceased building their own churches.

The west needs to come to grips with the reality that the broad education we value is not practical in all settings, that requiring it prevents work from being reproducible among the indigenous believers. Practical, focused training may be much more valuable. Steve Saint was able to get practical training in dentistry for a few Waodani. They have not been through all of dentist school, but they now can do much more than just pull a tooth. They can meet a very felt need among their people.

The church needs to think in terms of multiplying the kingdom rather than adding to the kingdom. Multiplication starts slower, but is much more effective in the long run. Saint uses the analogy of choosing whether to accept $100,000 a day for a month (31 days) or $.01 doubling everyday for the same month. Believe it or not, the penny doubled every day has a better return. On the last day alone the incoming funds total $10,737,418.24. The last day alone is greater than the $3,100,000 received over the whole month through addition.

If we want the world to know, we must reproduce a reproducible gospel among the world. We cannot simply add to our numbers.


Comments

2 responses to “The Great Omission”

  1. Hi Micah! Good to see you today. I am checking in with your blog again after a long hiatus (sorry). I like your thoughts and your Waodini story, yet i do think short-term projects have value but maybe more needs to be done with ministry partners (local and foreign) to contextualize the projects. As for western dependence, I’ve been thinking about finances and I have mixed feelings about economic development ministries that depend on Western money. On one hand it seems like its not sustainable but in a globalizing economy.. who knows. I have a lot to learn. Talk to you later.

  2. I whole heartedly agree that there is value in short term trips. This book did make me rethink some of how I believe they should be approached. But there is certainly significant value in short trips especially for those who go. Speaking from my own experience, it gives people a bigger picture of the world; it gives them ties to what God is doing around the world; it helps them pray with insight; it helps them be better supporters, better encouragers of those who have committed to be cross cultural long term.

    The book did make me aware of a whole set of dangers I hadn’t even really considered. I hadn’t thought how many dangers might be inherent in building a church for some folks. I’m not resolved that there is never a place for it. But I think I personally had not given it enough thought.

    On the money side of things, Steve Saint had an good analogy. He spoke of money as medicine and of the dangers of taking too much, or of taking it when not necessary, or not as prescribed. I think there is enough need for “medicine” in the world to take as much money as the West wants to give. Steve Saint just calls for more wisdom in giving it. He has used a lot of money to develop cheaper, practical, maintainable aircraft and dental equipment. Such development takes a lot of investment. But once the development has been done, it can make (in this case) aircraft and dental equipment a much more feasible option for a large number of people. The micro loans I have heard you mention are also an excellent use of money.

    I hope this does not have the tone of refutation. Any seeming refutation is out of fear that I misrepresented an author who I believe presented a balanced, thoughtful view. I’m not a fan of burning wagons just because fire looks cool. Some of my wordings were perhaps overly strong. Things like “the west needs to come to grips . . .” could probably have been said in a more helpful way.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *